What rekeying actually means
A pin-tumbler lock opens when the pins inside line up with the cuts on the key. Rekeying swaps those pins for a new set that matches a new key. The lock body, handle and finish stay put; every old key simply stops working. It is the same security result as new locks for most homes, at a fraction of the hardware cost.
You don't know who has a key
Unless you're the first person ever to live in the home, copies of the old key are out there. Think about who may have had one:
- Real estate agents and lockbox users
- Previous owners or tenants
- Their family, friends and neighbors
- Cleaning and repair crews
- Sitters, dog walkers and former roommates
A seller or landlord may say every key was returned. Nobody can promise that a copy wasn't cut at a hardware store years ago.
It's cheaper than new locks
Rekeying is listed on the price list from a starting price per lock, plus the service call fee. A locksmith can usually rekey several doors in one visit and key them all alike, so one key opens the front door, back door and garage entry. Fewer keys. Less to lose.
Renters: ask first
If you rent, the lock belongs to the property owner. Ask the landlord to rekey before you move in. Some will; others will let you arrange it yourself if they receive a copy of the new key. Arizona doesn't require a rekey between tenants, which is exactly why it's worth asking.
Renovations count too
Even long-time owners should consider a rekey after major work. Electricians, painters and contractors may have held keys for weeks. Once the job is done and the final invoice is paid, a rekey closes that chapter.
When replacement makes more sense
Rekeying assumes the lock is in good shape. If a deadbolt is loose, worn or a low grade, replace it. On exterior doors, ANSI Grade 1 or Grade 2 deadbolts are the usual recommendation.